Skip to content

Blog

How to Choose an Advertising Agency: 8 Criteria That Matter

By: Emre Öztürk15 min read
How to Choose an Advertising Agency: 8 Criteria That Matter

Choosing an advertising agency is really choosing a partner you will work with for years. Get it wrong and you lose more than budget: you lose time. Six months in, asking "why isn't this working?" and starting over is the most expensive outcome for most businesses.

We have been running an agency in Eskişehir, Türkiye, since 2012, working with brands across very different industries, and we hear the same question again and again: how do you choose an advertising agency, what should you look at, and what should you ask? This guide walks you through the process step by step, from your own preparation to signing the contract. The aim is to turn "who is the best agency?" into "who is the right agency for us?" and leave you with a checklist that works whichever agency you end up hiring.

Before you start: get clear on your own goals

The most common mistake is collecting proposals before defining the need. "We need some advertising" will get you five different proposals from five agencies, and you will have no fair way to compare them.

Before any meetings, write down answers to three questions:

  • What do you want? More phone calls, website enquiries, online sales, store visits or brand awareness. Each needs a different strategy.
  • How will you measure it? Decide up front which number tells you it is working: monthly leads, sales, bookings, or engagement rather than follower counts.
  • What can you spend? Keep the agency fee and the media budget (what you pay Google and Meta) separate. Lumping them together is one of the most common sources of misunderstanding.

Those three answers also form the backbone of a short brief. A good brief lets an agency put together a proposal that genuinely fits your business.

Which type of agency do you need?

"Advertising agency" is a broad label. Agencies specialise in different things, and working with the wrong model can make even a good agency feel like a poor fit.

Full-service agency

Handles everything from brand strategy and creative to web design, digital ads and video production under one roof. The upside is a consistent message across every channel and a single point of contact. It makes most sense for new brands or businesses repositioning themselves.

Digital and performance agency

Focuses on Google Ads, Meta ads, SEO and conversion-driven digital marketing. These teams are data-led: they analyse campaigns and keep optimising them. A strong option if your goal is measurable sales or leads and your brand identity is already settled.

Social media agency

Concentrates on content production, community management and paid social. Ask about their in-house photo and video capacity; on social, content quality decides the result.

Creative and design agency

Strong on logos, brand identity, packaging and campaign ideas. If you are wondering what a brand identity actually includes, our guide to corporate identity design is a good place to start.

For many businesses the right answer is an agency that offers several of these capabilities but has a real specialist behind each one. The way to find out is to meet the team.

8 criteria for choosing an advertising agency

Use these as a scorecard and rate every agency you meet against the same headings.

1. References and real work

Logos on a website don't tell you much. Ask for a project close to your industry or size, and ask exactly what the agency did on it. An agency that can clearly answer "what was the goal, and what changed?" actually ran that work.

If you can, ask for a quick call with a client reference. Confident agencies won't mind.

2. The team and how you will communicate

Is the person pitching the same person who will run your account day to day? Who owns the relationship, who designs, who manages the ad accounts? Meeting the team also shows you what the agency outsources.

Agree on a rhythm early: weekly or monthly meetings, and who you call when something is urgent.

3. Strategy first, or execution first?

A good agency doesn't open with a package. It asks questions first: about your audience, competitors, sales process and how customers find you. A conversation that starts with "this many posts and this many ads a month" usually means strategy is missing.

4. Measurement and reporting

A report isn't there for the agency to describe its work. It's there to help you make decisions. Ask:

  • Which metrics will you report, and how do they connect to my goal?
  • Who sets up Google Analytics, Search Console, conversion tracking and ad pixels?
  • Who interprets the report, and what changes next month as a result?

Reports full of likes and impressions that never mention sales or leads are a warning sign.

5. Account and data ownership

This one is often skipped, and it matters a lot. Your Google Ads account, Meta ad account, Analytics property, domain, hosting and social pages should be opened in your business's name, with the agency given access. If you part ways, your history and accounts stay with you.

6. Transparent pricing

Agency fees vary widely depending on scope, number of channels, content volume and the time the team will spend. So the most trustworthy proposal isn't the cheapest or the most expensive. It's the one with the clearest line items. You should see these listed separately:

  • The agency fee (monthly or per project)
  • Media spend paid to ad platforms
  • Extras such as shoots, production and licensed imagery
  • Number of revisions and delivery times

7. Creative quality and production capacity

Creative matters as much as targeting. Ask whether the agency handles design, photography and video in-house. Outsourcing product shoots or brand films every time slows things down and adds cost.

8. Culture and local knowledge

For businesses serving a local market, an agency that knows the city, the market and how local customers behave has a real edge. An agency working for a restaurant, clinic or manufacturer in Eskişehir gets campaigns on target faster if it already knows local search habits and competitors. A local agency also makes face-to-face meetings and shoot planning much easier.

Questions to ask in the agency meeting

Take this list along and ask every agency the same things:

  1. Which project similar to ours have you worked on, and what was the result?
  2. What would you do in the first 90 days?
  3. Who will handle our account day to day?
  4. Which number will we use to measure success?
  5. Whose name will the ad accounts be in?
  6. How long is the contract, and what are the exit terms?
  7. What do you do when a campaign doesn't perform?

The last one matters most. Not every campaign works first time; what counts is how quickly the agency notices and how it fixes things.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed results. Promises like "first page of Google in a month" or "guaranteed sales" aren't realistic. Rankings and ad performance depend on factors nobody fully controls.
  • No access to your accounts. If you can't see your ad account, you can't see how your budget is spent.
  • One package for everyone. Off-the-shelf packages built before anyone understands your business are usually designed around the agency's workflow, not your goals.
  • A vague contract. A contract that doesn't spell out scope, deadlines and termination terms is a dispute waiting to happen.

Compare proposals, then start small

Three proposals are enough for most businesses. Compare what's inside each line, not just the total: if one agency offers twelve designs a month plus ad management and another offers ad management only, they aren't quoting for the same job.

Before signing a long contract, start with a two- to three-month trial period or a single project, such as one campaign or a new website. It gives both sides a chance to see how the partnership works, and at the end you can decide based on the metrics you set at the start.

Example: a local business choosing an agency

Picture a café opening a new branch in Eskişehir. Its goal is to turn neighbourhood visitors into regulars in the first three months.

  • Brief: Students and office workers within two kilometres; success means weekday lunchtime occupancy.
  • Services needed: Google Business Profile and local search optimisation, Instagram content, launch-period Meta ads, venue and product photography.
  • Selection criteria: An agency that shoots in-house, has local advertising experience and reports on occupancy and promo-code redemptions.

Here the right choice isn't the biggest agency or the cheapest quote, but the one whose skills match the need.

How we work at MCW Ajans

We have been based in Eskişehir since 2012. Every partnership starts with a kickoff meeting to pin down the business goal and how we will measure it. We open ad accounts in our clients' names and build reports around leads and sales.

Everything sits under one roof:

Visibility in AI search is now worth raising when you choose an agency, too. Our guide to adding your business to ChatGPT is a good starting point.

The bottom line

Choosing an advertising agency isn't a price comparison; it's a test of fit. Write your goal down, decide which type of agency you need, apply the same eight criteria to every candidate and test the partnership with a short trial. Whichever agency you pick, that approach makes sure your budget goes to the right place.

If you'd like to talk through what could work for your business, get in touch through our contact page or at hello@mcwajans.com. We'll start by getting your goal clear together.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for when choosing an advertising agency?

+

Relevant references, the team who will actually run your account, a strategy-first approach, reporting tied to your goals, ad accounts in your business's name, clearly itemised pricing, in-house creative production and knowledge of your local market.

Which is the best advertising agency?

+

There is no single best agency for everyone. The right one is the agency whose skills match your goals, industry and budget, and who reports results in a measurable way.

Is the agency fee the same as the ad budget?

+

No. The agency fee pays for the team's strategy, design and management work. The ad budget is media spend paid directly to platforms such as Google and Meta. A good proposal lists the two separately.

Whose name should the ad accounts be in?

+

Your Google Ads account, Meta ad account, Analytics, domain and social pages should be opened in your business's name, with the agency given access. That way your data stays with you if you change agencies.

Why work with a local advertising agency?

+

A local agency knows the market, the competitors and how people search in your area, and face-to-face meetings and shoots are easier to arrange. For businesses serving local customers, that gets campaigns on target faster.

Let's make great work together.

Let's start a project